Combe Capelle burial re-dated

Print
Share 
Tuesday, March 1, 2011  |  Featured, News

A team of scientists have managed to unlock the secrets surrounding the dating of the burial site of Combe Capelle that was discovered by the Swiss researcher and archaeologist Otto Hauser in 1909.

The cliff of Combe Capelle in August 1909 with the site indicated by the arrow © Photo: Wegner Archive

The cliff of Combe Capelle in August 1909 with the site indicated by the arrow © Photo: Wegner Archive

Otto Hauser with parts of the skeleton and skull from Combe Capelle  © Photo: Wegner Archive

Otto Hauser with parts of the skeleton and skull from Combe Capelle © Photo: Wegner Archive

Since his sensational discovery, the site of Combe Capelle, situated in the Couze valley in the Périgord region of southern France, has long been considered to be the earliest evidence of the remains of modern Homo sapiens anywhere in Europe.

Due to the circumstances of the find however, doubt was sometimes cast on its speculative dating of more than 30,000 years old and its connection with the transition to the Upper Palaeolithic period (Châtelperronian). In spite of this, the remains (buried with a chain of perforated shells) were nevertheless thought to have originated in the Ice Age.

After an initial sample of the famous skull failed to yield results in radiocarbon dating, a second sample was taken from a molar in the lower jaw for testing in June 2009 in Kiel.

In previous cases, compact tooth enamel had shown better preservation conditions of the collagen needed for radiocarbon dating. A sufficient amount of collagen was extracted after preparation and intense cleaning of the tooth.

Subsequent analysis using accelerator mass spectrometry at the laboratory in Kiel assigned a date of 7575 BCE to the remains of what had previously been assumed to be an early Homo sapiens specimen, meaning earlier assumptions had been out by several thousands of years.

The new dating for the site at Combe Capelle not only underscores the fact that finds of early anatomically modern humans, pre-dating 30,000 years ago, are extremely rare in Europe, but also confirms the trend that we have no evidence of burials from that early period.

The skeleton laid out at the time of discovery. © Photo: Wegner Archive

The skeleton laid out at the time of discovery. © Photo: Wegner Archive

The Combe Capelle skull in January 2002. © Photo: Claudia Plamp

The Combe Capelle skull. © Photo: Claudia Plamp 2002

At the same time, it has become clear that Châtelperronian culture in France was practised exclusively by the last Neanderthals. The new date places the crouched inhumation site from the rock shelter of Combe Capelle in the Middle Stone Age (Mesolithic), when humans lived in warm climatic conditions and survived by hunting, fishing and gathering nuts and berries, including hazelnuts. Inhumations from the later Middle Stone Age are also exceptionally rare in Europe, and as such, the site of Combe Capelle still remains an outstanding testament of European prehistory, even if the final date has changed so significantly.

The team of scientists involved in the project comprised members from Berlin’s Museum of Prehistory and Early History, Universität Greifswald, the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig and the Leibniz Laboratory for Radiometric Dating and Stable Isotope Research in Kiel.

Learn more

 


2 Comments


  1. Hello. This is most interesting. Is there a paper, a link or at least a name, confirming this claim.

    I really do not doubt you are saying the truth but I find it very odd and annoying that no reference is provided at all.

  2. Apologies about no link to a reference, there was none available, the press release was from the
    Berlin's Museum of Prehistory and Early History http://www.smb.museum/smb/ueberuns/index.php?p=2&…
    they worked with Universität Greifswald, http://www.uni-kiel.de/leibniz/Leibniz-web_englis… the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig http://www.eva.mpg.de/evolution/ and the Leibniz Laboratory for Radiometric Dating and Stable Isotope Research in Kiel – http://www.uni-kiel.de/leibniz/Leibniz-web_englis… – none of whom mention this on their websites either. However, I have hyper linked these institutions if you wish to contact them.

    I would suggest the Leibniz Laboratory as the first stop.

Leave a Reply